I think another reason I’m pro Damon/Elena is that I honestly don’t believe it’s ever going to happen. It’s fairly obvious that the showrunners want Elena to pick Stefan – she might make out with Damon and maybe even shag him before the story’s over, but come on, does anyone really think they’ll end up together long-term?
Either she’s going to get with Stefan and live broodily ever after, or she will choose herself and have a regular human life (still my preference, unless she gets vamped, in which case if she doesn’t want eternity to be boring she should go with Damon). Damon’s not the kind of character that writers ever want to be happy. It’s far more entertaining to bring him to the edge of happiness and then destroy him over and over again. Trust me, I know this one.
I do love to root for an underdog, though.
Okay, so, another episode that divided people. To be perfectly honest…I kind of hated it. No, hate’s a strong word. There were maybe two scenes that didn’t make me roll my eyes or throw stuffed animals at the screen. The one comfort was knowing that there’s still two more episodes where all this ridiculous shit can be set right. We know our show does endings like whoa.
I was discussing S3 with my Tweeps, and what I realized was that this season started to go off kilter right when the big witchcraft started. It was fine when it was Bonnie making daylight rings and doing stuff solo – and even fine when it was Klaus’s witches in season 2 – but between Abby and Esther and the 1000 dead witch spirits becoming this massive deux ex machina in practically every plotline, y’all, I’m over it. There are all these rules about vampires, but the only rule for witches is apparently “do it too much and you’ll get a nosebleed,” sort of the hairy palms myth for spellcasters.
Because apparently Esther can do whatever the hell she wants and it’s all good. All she needs is a little Doppelganger blood. Doppelganger blood is like the baking soda of this show – it does everything, fixes all problems, and leaves kitchen fixtures shiny and new.
(SPOILERY stuff starts after the image)

I think what really angered me was beyond that, though – it was that I felt Alaric’s “death” was totally cheapened by the last scene. We went through that torment, watching everyone say goodbye. He got a peaceful death, knowing he was loved, which he deserved. He didn’t have to worry about hurting anyone else.
No, wait! ESTHER’S ALL UP ON IT!
Someone really, REALLY needs to teach Bonnie Occlumency. Jesus Christ.
Haus of Klaus
Klaus is working on a gigantic painting that looks a lot like one of the cypress trees Van Gogh painted while in a mental institution. Just putting that out there.
ESTHERBEKA: Stake.
KLAUS: Gimme it.
Klaus burns the stake and announces his intention to leave Mystic Falls with his Doppelganger, which solves the tricky “I don’t want to die a violent screaming death, but I can’t possibly leave a town that has Elena Gilbert’s magical unicorn ladybits in it!” conundrum everyone seems to have.
ESTHERBEKA: But the dance! I’m on the committee! And Caroline will be there.
KLAUS: Aw, what the hell. Surely I, a thousand year old bloodthirsty murdery creature who destroys everything in my path can spare a night of frivolity to woo a girl who has yet to express any real interest in me whatsoever.
One thing this show does so well is make the primary motivation of all people, whether human or vampire or werewolf or hybrid, the desire to be loved. They all feel alienated even among their closest friends, and they all crave the feeling of being understood that always slips from their grasp.
Well, except Esther, but I’ve come to think of her as less a character and more a walking, snotty plot device.
Salvatore Den of Antiquities
Damon calls to check in on Ric, who claims he’s leaving town for a few days to clear his head.
For some reason Damon’s reaction is more, “Did I leave the gas on?” than “Is it a good idea to let the psycho who kills vampires and the humans who help them just vanish for a couple of days without any supervision whatsoever and just assume he’ll take his herbs like a good boy?”
Jesus Christ, these people.
Come to find out, Evilaric was the one calling, and he’s currently at Haus of Klaus, hanging out in the coffin room. Man, vampire sense of smell just gets worse all the time.
ESTHERBEKA: Okay, now, dagger me so I can get out of this body.
I’m not really sure why they do this, unless she needs to be in her body for Big Magic – but we’ve seen that people wearing vampires and vice versa can do things the body couldn’t do before, so….?
Okay, every time in this episode the witchcraft does something that makes me want to gouge my eyes out, you’ll see this: SHENANIGANS. Otherwise this recap is going to be 50 pages long. I won’t even go into the whys – just assume when you see the word I’m banging my head against the screen in futility.
Mystic Falls Gym of Absolute and Total Safety for Students and Faculty
Caroline and Elena (as well as Matt and Jeremy) are hard at work decorating for the dance. Caroline snarks on Rebekah’s decorating taste and how she didn’t even bother to show up today, then proceeds to put on a leotard and do a one-woman synchronized swimming routine on Why Elena Should Be With Stefan.
Apparently Stefan is her “Epic Love.” Pardon me, I misplaced my barf bucket.
I found Caroline irritating in this episode, which is rare. Her cheerleading routine for Stefan sounded really shrill and contrived. Otherwise after everything that Stefan has done to Elena, how could Elena’s best friend possibly cheer them on as a couple? Caroline herself is the one that last season went on about how impossible human/vampire relationships are…but wait sorry, Stefan’s Elena’s EPIC LOVE.
Whatthefuckever, Caroline.
CAROLINE: It’s Stefan’s turn to woo you, Elena!
ELENA: What about the season and a half he got before, when we were constantly in danger and I was pretty miserable most of the time even before he went on his first killing spree and then tried to drive me off a bridge?
CAROLINE: EPIC LOVE. Besides the season’s almost over! We have to get this triangle shit as tense as we can so that when you pick Stefan it’ll be extra special!
Den of Antiquities
So, Elena calls Stefan to ask her to the dance, and there’s all that awkward exes fumbling around.
ELENA: So…even though we haven’t discussed my making out with your brother last episode, that’s probably not even going to come up, because it’s not like that was *real* kissing. It was “me trying to figure stuff out” kissing. Obviously it doesn’t count. Let’s go dancing!
STEFAN: Yay!
Damon sees part of this exchange and it’s hard to tell if the look on his face is more “I can’t believe that girl” or “Oh fuck it, you deserve each other.”
Mystic Falls General
Damon freaks Meredith out with…well, with his personality, and asks Meredith if she thinks Alaric can stay non-killy if he didn’t even bother taking his jar of herbs with him on his vision quest. Meredith’s expression says “Um…no.”
Salvatore Crypt
Esther and Evilaric approach the crypt, Esther explaining that this spot was where Klaus tore her heart from her chest, and therefore it’s special. Violent death marks the ground, you see.
So…most of Mystic Falls is going to be marked like a motherfucker, right?
Esther explains in her usual pontificatory voice that since the Last Pointy MacGuffin will burn up whenever it’s used, they need to make it multi-use, and that involves melting Alaric’s ring, which doubles in volume upon melting, all over it. SHENANIGANS
Gilbert House
Stefan shows up to pick up Elena, who is looking rather cute in her little flapper dress, and that’s me saying that as someone who pretty much hated the 20’s.
STEFAN: Here, I got you one lame-ass flower. That makes up for all the mean stuff I said and did to you and your friends, right?
ELENA: Totes. Let’s go!
Have you noticed how when Elena’s in shots with Stefan that are supposed to be romantic, she’s made up like a teenager (or a child), but in shots with Damon she wears way more eyeliner and mascara, even to bed? Just an observation.
Stefan points out, quite rightly, that their dance karma is kind of on “dung beetle” level, but Elena is undaunted. Seriously, I’m with Stefan on this one – by now Elena should be barricaded in her house with a cache of military grade weapons and ten years’ worth of canned beans.
Ain’t No Party Like a MFHS Party, Cuz a MFHS Party Got No Chaperones!
Music, dancing, disco ball…which I don’t get…what is supposed to make this look like the 20s again? Besides the costumes. The kids are all flailing around pretty convincingly. Lots of elbows. It’s epic.
Caroline and Tyler get their flirt on. Caroline looks adorable too.
Unfortunately Caroline has appointed herself Destroyer of Romantic Illusions, as she tells Matt not to get up on Elena since people tend to get hurt around her. Aha, maybe that’s it! Maybe she’s pushing Stefan on Elena so that Stefan will get killed.
*sigh*
Moments later Tyler shows up and informs Caroline he’s determined to sweep her off her feet. Tyler actually admits point-blank to being jealous of Klaus, which is way more emotionally mature than 90% of teenage boys, so go Tyler!
In order for the CW to make back the cash it spent on sets and extras, we’re treated to a number of crowd shots and moments of the various cast members dancing and twirling their fringe.
Then, Elena decides now is a great time to tell Stefan she made out with his brother (kind of like the last time, when Stefan was on the ground bleeding), but thankfully, Stefan doesn’t want to hear about it; he gives her a very fair and grown-up speech about how he’s just happy to be her date tonight.
Which on the surface seems really cool of him, but when you think about it, the fact that Elena doesn’t protest, and doesn’t bring it up again, tells you all you really need to know about who she’s going to pick. If she honestly had any intention of choosing Damon, she would try harder to explain things to Stefan, because she has always felt like she has to justify everything to him. Not to mention Stefan being all cool about it is the behavior of someone who already knows the outcome. At this point it’s all about the show picking the right background song for their tender yet epic reunion sex.
Luckily for the plot, which is flopping around on the bottom of the boat by now, Damon shows up and informs the two that they need to talk.
Jeremy sees the trio head off out of the gym and follows. He bumps into Bonnie and Jamie.
JEREMY: Oh, hey, dude – sorry I bumped into you. You’re probably going to die, just so you know.
BONNIE: Why are you wearing that ring?
JEREMY: Because my sister is hoping she’ll end up with no family at all so she can run off with her vampire of choice with no ties to this stupid little town. Bye!
Outside, the trio square off on the Alaric Problem.
DAMON: Kill him.
STEFAN: Rehabilitate him.
ELENA: Whatever you guys think.
Jeremy stalks up just long enough to register his disapproval on the whole kill-Alaric thing, then huffs away in anger rather than offering a viable solution.
Elena follows him outside, insisting that nobody’s going to hurt Ric; Jeremy seems to believe it about as much as we do.
ESTHER: Elena, You Must Come With Me.
ELENA: Oh for fuck’s sake, not you again.
ESTHER: Willingly Or Not You Will Come With Me To Save Your Friend Alaric.
And Elena, of course, skips blithely along after her, telling Jeremy to fetch the brothers.
At this point we find out that in the last nanosecond Esther has somehow laid down a six-inch-thick salt line around what I assume is at least the whole gym if not the whole school and sealed the vampires in. In full view of a hundred teenagers.
SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS
DAMON: Hey, Jeremy, you’re human – kick the salt line so it’s broken, and we’ll waltz right out of here.
JEREMY: Hey, great idea!
Jeremy kicks the salt line as do a dozen other people walking through it, rendering the boundary nonexistent.
NO, WAIT. THEY ALL JUST STAND THERE. THEY DON’T EVEN TRY!
SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS
Meanwhile, in an empty classroom, Bonnie and Jamie talk about her friends, Jamie expressing that they’re not exactly the Brady Bunch.
I gotta say the girls’ outfits in this ep are pretty fabulous, even though I hate 20s fashion – it only flatters women built basically straight up and down with a minimum of natural curve, and luckily that describes most television actresses. Bonnie’s looking pretty swanky. Jamie on the other hand looks like a cast extra from the “Chim Chim Cheree” scene in Mary Poppins.
That doesn’t stop Bonnie from pouncing on the guy–and I mean pouncing. Go Bonnie! They get a couple of seconds of teenage normalcy before Damon, who is the Official Cockblocker of Episode 320, appears with his patented “We’ve got a problem.”
I’ve never been a huge Bonnie fan but damn, that girl never catches a break, does she? All her friends get laid – Elena’s got hot and cold running Salvatores and Caroline has a werewolf on one hand and Klaus on the other, and either girl could snap her fingers and turn her house into the Kama Sutra, but Bonnie can’t even make out for five minutes without someone needing some lame-ass spell.
Graveyard, Crypt-Adjacent
Esther tosses Elena some bullshit about how she’s sorry to drag her away from her funtimes, but the Doppelganger always gets blood-sucked by somebody or another. Elena begs her not to hurt Alaric, but Evilaric appears to let her know that’s not really the issue at hand.
Apparently Esther wants to make an Ubervamp out of Alaric, because that would obviously solve everything, and something about his hatred of vampires being pure and uncompromising and SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS.
Oh, and also, Esther was hanging out in the afterlife cranking up Alaric’s Evil-o-meter to 11 every time he died. Which…doesn’t explain why Samantha Gilbert went evil, unless Esther was oh fuck it SHENANIGANS.
Back at the Dance
Tyler and Caroline are cozy on the dance floor when who should arrive but Klaus, looking insanely classy and dapper in a white suit.
Klaus cuts in on their dance, which Caroline objects to but Tyler, pretending to still be sired, obliges to, leading to probably the best exchange in the whole episode:
CAROLINE: Why do you always have to prove you’re the alpha male?
KLAUS: I don’t have to prove anything, love, I am the alpha male.
Klaus pours on the charm, but Caroline’s not having it.
KLAUS: Baby, if I could rearrange the alphabet of my childhood, I’d put the rune for U and the rune for I together and it would probably create a binding runescript that would blight the crops for four years but that’s okay because you so fine.
CAROLINE: What?
KLAUS: I’m leaving tomorrow, and I know you won’t come with me–but one of these days you’ll realize that this town is incredibly boring (once everyone’s dead that is) and you’ll come looking for me so bye.
Klaus stalks outside, but stops short when he sees the magic salt line that still hasn’t been walked through by a single person.
STEFAN: Yo mama.
Inside, Bonnie is muttering her seven words of witch latin (THESMATOS, BITCHES!) I assume to break the barrier spell.
Klaus’s idea of speeding things up is to try and strangle Jamie. Well, sure.
STEFAN: Come on, Klaus, threatening Bonnie’s boo isn’t the way to go. If she’s all shaky and stuttering she might accidentally turn us all into wheat smut. Step off and let her chant, dude.
Klaus, being sired to Stefan and all, lets Jamie go. Finally Jeremy and Matt figure out that humans can leave the school, so they can stop Esther.
Graveyard
While Esther lights a zillion candles (Bonnie can light them with her brain, you know. Just sayin.) Elena tries to do that reasoning thing with Ric, and it works about as well as her reasoning always does, meaning, it gets Ric to tell us more about his evil side and that’s about it.
Esther magics blood out of Elena…even though nobody’s ever done that before SHENANIGANS! And starts her spell, which of course has to end in stabbity.
Mystic High
Bonnie pauses in the urgency of finding Esther to give Damon some of her patented self-righteousness. I haven’t noticed her giving Stefan any, even though both of them were in on the whole let’s kill Abby thing. Actually if Bonnie’s going to be pissed at anyone who was down with that plan, she’d have to be mad at THE ENTIRE FANDOM.
Over in the now-empty gym (is there anything sadder than an empty gym still decorated for a school dance?) Caroline tries to reassure Tyler that he’s not going to get killed, but Tyler’s feeling a bit morose and wonders if they shouldn’t just let Esther kill Klaus.
TYLER: I hate Klaus! I let him dance with you!
CAROLINE: Um…how exactly were you going to prevent that, bucko? Did you get some reinforcing steel rods installed in your neck so he can’t slap your head off?
TYLER: I got your steel rod right here.
CAROLINE: *slurp*
Graveyard
Elena de-stakes dead Evilaric, while Esther continues to pontificate about how righteous she is and how this is NOTHING like what she did to her kids, because of…the reason. Oh, okay, Alaric will die once he’s done, so instead of creating an immortal race of murderers, she’s destroying a good human to create a rage-filled robot to do her bidding which she will then kill.
Yeah, sure. That’s way better. Bitch.
We do find out that Alaric might be himself again for a minute when he wakes up before the transition is complete. Gee, I wonder if that will be important later?
Esther makes the mistake of playing the Jenna card, and Elena about scratches her face off.
Okay, mostly she just stands there crying, but still, she’s clearly unhappy about it.
Just as an aside, I HATE the way Esther says “vampire.” I just want to punch her in the head every time it comes out of her mouth. Actually I want to punch her in the head every second she’s on screen, so since she says “vampire” every third word, it works out well for me.
Just then Jeremy and Matt show up, armed and semi-dangerous, except that Esther uses her witchy mojo to make them point their weapons at each other because Esther’s magic can do anything. SHENANIGANS.
But before she can make them fire, being so protective of human life and all,
ALALARIC: Temporarily sane me FTW!
He stabs the bejesus out of her, and she goes down.
Alaric clearly has no memory of the last day or two, which means he doesn’t know what Esther has done to him–by Elena’s quivering lip we know she’ll be the one to tell him.
The School, Outside
Klaus and Stefan circle each other trading quips and barbs. Then Damon shows up, and Klaus needles the boys about Elena picking one over the other, but it’s nothing we haven’t heard before.
Bonnie comes outside to let them know the boundary is lifted. I think it would have been funny for her to just hang out and let them think it was still there for like twelve hours while everyone else dealt with the situation, then called Stefan and was all, “BAZINGA!”
The Crypt
Jeremy tells Alaric and Elena that Damon’s there and that Klaus took Esther’s body. He can tell by their faces that something’s up.
ALARIC: Jeremy…I’m not going to become an Ubervamp.
JEREMY: But I’ve already got the action figure!
The next few scenes are excruciating, which makes the ending piss me off even more, but:
Alaric says his goodbyes to his kids, and somehow Elena makes their goodbye about her (It’s all my fault!) as if he didn’t have any choice in his own fate. She claims that she forced him to stay there and take care of her and Jeremy even though he didn’t want to be part of it.
ALARIC: Oh, Elena…we both know I didn’t “take care” of jack shit. But it’s been great, really…almost like I had a purpose in life for a while.
Alaric walks Elena out of the crypt, to find that almost the entire cast is standing around in a semicircle, showing Alaric he’s not alone. It’s incredibly touching other than the fact that it’s got the fucking Fray in the background. That guy’s voice is like nails in my brain.
The camera moves from face to face, and we see Damon in three-quarter profile trying to look strong, and Matt with red eyes, and then finally Meredith.
Alaric gives a nod and a small smile, then walks into the crypt and shuts the door behind him.
Haus of Klaus
Klaus undaggers Rebekah, and takes the opportunity to yell at his dead mother in her coffin.
You know, at this point, the wise thing would be to burn her body and sow her ashes with salt. Please?
Bonnie’s House
Wait…Bonnie has a HOUSE? SHE LIVES SOMEWHERE? No way! Next thing you know we’ll meet her dad!
Jamie comforts Bonnie. That’s basically it.
Mystic Grill
Matt and Jeremy have a drink in Alaric’s honor.
The DEA bursts into the bar and arrests Matt for serving alcohol to a minor.
Nah, just kidding. Jeremy cries. He’s rocking the single man-tear pretty well, I must say.
The School
Elena, who is long overdue for a screaming fit, is trying to clean out Alaric’s office in that way people in shock usually do before having a screaming fit. Stefan interrupts her and convinces her to follow him.
He leads her to the sad, empty gym and reminds her this is where he bit her and killed Dana and turned off his feelers.
ELENA: That’s really comforting, Stefan thanks.
Stefan starts talking about how Elena told him feelings are good and being sad is okay, but all I can really focus on is how his hair looks like the feathered crest of some sort of bird, or possibly Quetzalcoatl. At some point, though, something he says makes Elena start sobbing and hug him.
The Crypt
Meredith and Damon actually bond a little, which pleases me. I like the thought of them getting closer after Alaric’s death.
Meredith tells him he shouldn’t leave Ric alone to die, and after a moment Damon seems to agree; he joins Ric in the crypt, bringing along one last bottle of booze.
Alaric makes fun of Damon for giving Rose a pre-death paradise dream, and it’s so sad and funny, because their relationship has always been one of the best things on the show – they should hate each other, and sort of do in a way, but depend on each other far more.
And now Damon’s going to be left without his bestie, and Elena and Jeremy without their doomed mostly-inept parental figure, and Meredith without her squeeze, and all so that Esther could further her stupid agenda that doesn’t even entirely make sense.
As they sit quipping at each other and passing the bottle, we can see the tears falling from Alaric’s eye that Damon can’t see.
Bonnie’s House
For reasons I can’t even begin to fathom, Bonnie and Jamie are still in costume as they sleep spooning – what the hell? In that getup, I’d have changed into my jammies the minute I walked in the house, especially after a night like that, boy or no boy. At least men’s clothes are marginally comfortable regardless of the decade – can you imagine trying to sleep on all those damn beads?
So a whispering voice wakes Bonnie up, and who should it be but Esther’s spirit calling from beyond the grave telling her to “finish her work.”
About this time I get a terrible gnawing feeling in my gut realizing what’s going to happen, and I’m tempted to throw my remote at the screen so hard I don’t have to see it.
The Crypt
Alaric finally drifts off, and Damon, with tears in his eyes, finishes the bottle of booze with a salute to his friend.
As he walks out, though, he’s confronted by Bonnie. Damon doesn’t get that anything’s wrong at first – in fact he’s remarkably nice to her for Damon, probably since he just lost his BFF and all. Bonnie gives him a witchy migraine for his trouble.
Bonnie marches into the tomb and cuts open her palm (what IS it with these people and bleeding from palms? Not the best choice! Not even in the top 20!) then forces Alaric, who I guess still had a little life left in him, to drink it.
Alaric gets up, all veiny and blood-dripping, holding the Last Pointy MacGuffin (now with optional chrome trim), and I assume his programming kicks in.
SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS SHENANIGANS.



















